The real reason Boeing's new plane crashed twice

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 19 024

  • Christopher Evans
    Christopher Evans  48 minutes back

    Design hackers.

    • QuarioQuario54321
      QuarioQuario54321  2 hours back

      Boeing’s only good solution is to delete the program and make a completely new plane that would be different enough that existing pilots have to go through a change like an A220 pilot learning to fly a 777-300ER.

      • Jeffrey Collier
        Jeffrey Collier  2 hours back

        I have to disagree with two main points of your presentation. Lives and reputations are at stake here, so it is very important to be as accurate as possible. First of all, the FAA would not certify the 737MAX under the same type rating as the rest of the 737 family because its STALL CHARACTERISTICS were different, not because of the tendency of the MAX to pitch up on takeoff. This is in fact due to the placement of the new, larger CFM LEAP engines. BTW, the sitting height of the MAX on the ground has also increased, by 9 inches. Additionally, in the Ethiopian crash, the crew made two critical errors. They did not disengage the auto throttles, which remained engaged and it the full thrust takeoff setting. They did in fact correctly disengage the two elevator trim switches, which would by design disable the MCAS system. However, because of the high thrust setting, the air loads on the elevator were so high that the crew had great difficulty manually trimming the elevator, and subsequently, turned the elevator trim switches back on in order to electrically trim the elevator again. Unfortunately, this move proved fatal because it also reengaged the faulty MCAS system, which caused additional nose down trim and eventually led to the crash.

        • J-Man
          J-Man  2 hours back

          It is a terrible loss for the families and to those who lost their lives

          Complicit in this is the United States Government as well as Boeing . But ultimately the finamcial.cost of this horriblentragedy will be carried twice by the tax payer . Boeing is heavily subsidized by the US Government and therefore all compensatory damage will be paid once by the tax payer that subsidizes Boeing and then again when the Government is Sued by the families of victims .

          And not a single person will be charged with manslaughter for their negligence in the charge of duty they had to protect the lives of its passengers . But the rich got richer for a time and they will skate on by with no prison term while someone who got caught selling weed 3 times is serving a life sentence.

          These families should take everything from Boeing. This was no accident .

          • vn01208503
            vn01208503  3 hours back

            THIS SHOULD BE A MURDER CASE

            • UMU-i-D
              UMU-i-D  3 hours back

              As long as it helps our economy it's OK!

              • CrazyGames
                CrazyGames  3 hours back

                The 5K dislikes are Boeing employees

                • Lyle Gorch
                  Lyle Gorch  4 hours back

                  The Free Market is the solution to every problem. De-regualate EVERYTHING.

                  • Dutch iRacer
                    Dutch iRacer  4 hours back

                    My wife and daughter are going to fly Boeing in 2 months, not happy about it and I told them to cancel if it is a 737 MAX even if we have to pay the ticket ourselves.

                    • Crazy Monkeys
                      Crazy Monkeys  4 hours back

                      I haven't been on a plane in 6 years but when I do get onto one I hope that it goes well.

                      • Sphinx Rising
                        Sphinx Rising  4 hours back

                        VOX, a bunch of snowflakes preying on the ignorant masses for Likes, Shares, & Sub, SMH.

                        • dnadeau819
                          dnadeau819  5 hours back

                          I've always like Airbus better. I'm not gonna be ignorant just because their usa made. If its Boeing I ain't going!!!

                          • Kenzie Lehman
                            Kenzie Lehman  5 hours back

                            Who else is watching this because their flight was changed due to them not being able to fly on the 737
                            Just me? Ok

                            • Sumeet S
                              Sumeet S  5 hours back

                              Thank god Boeing didn't name their new software as 'Anti Stall Software' otherwise instead of MCAS we would have heard something else

                              • Jeet Chakrabarti
                                Jeet Chakrabarti  5 hours back

                                Boeing isn't facing more scrutiny because its a bunch of Asians and Africans that died if this happened in America it would have been a human cry. Boeing would be asked to pay through their noses, company might even get bankrupt!!! But since Asians and Africans Died lets ground aircraft fix the aircrafts and lets all be on our merry way.

                                • FUGLY
                                  FUGLY  6 hours back

                                  Money money money.

                                  • Makate Rapulana
                                    Makate Rapulana  6 hours back

                                    Corruption

                                    • vsuperstar69
                                      vsuperstar69  6 hours back

                                      Greedy bastards

                                      • silentwarrior3509
                                        silentwarrior3509  7 hours back

                                        What scumbags. It's always about money, isn't it? Are you happy now, Boeing?

                                        • Dexter Francis
                                          Dexter Francis  7 hours back

                                          This analysis by Vaughn Cordle and Don McGregor is a must read; https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/boeing-737-max-8-crashes-case-pilot-error-vaughn-cordle-cfa/?fbclid=IwAR0jbyU3W3MRoSDxXr1idIy65EUiL6tI5ZxQPjwqpWHJMeiHzFhQUXAzzsA

                                          • Michael Sebourn
                                            Michael Sebourn  7 hours back

                                            people are rich still want more money

                                            • Joshua Morai
                                              Joshua Morai  7 hours back

                                              Oh look. Boeing sold the two planes as extras now ppl are died :(

                                              • M S
                                                M S  8 hours back

                                                There is no plane that doesn’t have quirky handling characteristics under various conditions. All designs have their compromises between aerodynamic efficiency and utility. Planes go through many design changes in their life, too include the placement of the engine on the wing. That’s nothing new. I don’t like Boeing, not because they don’t make great planes because they do. I don’t like them because their planes are overrated and their employees are a bunch of unionized babies. These two incidents have many things in common with accidents in decades past with other planes, but they never mention those because this story is being used politically both domestically and internationally. You all believe what you want, but there are parts of this story that are being exaggerated, and parts that are flat out being left out. All to serve a purpose. I don’t necessarily prefer Boeing to Airbus, but you can all start acting like The Lord of the Flies if you want. Because that’s what self serving animals do, they use opportunities like this to serve their own ambitions for power, money and fame by exploiting the weak minded to do things far worse. As far as Vox and their credibility, it’s not hard to scroll back, even within the last year, and find stuff they mentioned as facts, and were not. Vox is like Wikipedia to me, it’s good only as a starting point, but I wouldn’t rely on it.

                                                • Danny L
                                                  Danny L  8 hours back

                                                  I need a better explanation on why the engine placement increased pitch angle

                                                  • Dexter Francis
                                                    Dexter Francis  7 hours back

                                                    Danny - It's the result of the airflow over the LEAP engine nacelle contributing to the lift being generated by the wings. It doesn't increase pitch angle as much as it adds to the torque around the lateral axis of the aircraft around the center of gravity, which can move forward or aft about four feet in flight and still be within the aircraft's safe CG envelope.

                                                • Lloyd Townsend
                                                  Lloyd Townsend  8 hours back

                                                  This is capitalism people. Capitalism kills people and the earth. If it's a Boeing I'm not going!

                                                  • Anuj Kapoor
                                                    Anuj Kapoor  8 hours back

                                                    Watch this, that is if it's not censored in the USA. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvkEpstd9os

                                                    • Russell Lee
                                                      Russell Lee  8 hours back

                                                      Boeing's aircraft are dangerous. 737, 777, 787. All grounded at one point. Money trumping safety now.

                                                      • S Cholensky
                                                        S Cholensky  8 hours back

                                                        Boeing has some serious internal issues. Disregarding safety, cutting corners, and putting profit above all else isn't the exception at Boeing, it has become the norm. Eye-opening documentary shows the same behavior in the Dreamliner program: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvkEpstd9os



                                                        If anyone knows of similar issues within Airbus, please comment with links.

                                                        • Anuj Kapoor
                                                          Anuj Kapoor  9 hours back

                                                          The only reason Boeing will get away with this is because it wasn't American People who lost their lives. FAA the agency that was supposed to work for the safety of the People did the exact opposite. The Government and its agencies are run by big companies. The President is Friends with CEO of Boeing. Conflict of Interest is written all over this story. It just makes me sad I hope people responsible for those innocent lives are brought to justice.

                                                          • Didier Lemoine
                                                            Didier Lemoine  9 hours back

                                                            Boeing wanted to make money very quick !

                                                            • Didier Lemoine
                                                              Didier Lemoine  9 hours back

                                                              they should hv put longer legs instead of modifying the plane balance feature !

                                                              • 林航
                                                                林航  9 hours back

                                                                So Sad after watching this

                                                                • meg rai
                                                                  meg rai  9 hours back

                                                                  Competition with rival killed many people😟. Thank you for sharing what exactly happened.

                                                                  • Arc
                                                                    Arc  10 hours back

                                                                    F*** This AIRPLANE!!!! Deep condolences to all victims. RIP

                                                                    • Rick S
                                                                      Rick S  10 hours back

                                                                      CEO should be put in prison...

                                                                      • Rick S
                                                                        Rick S  10 hours back

                                                                        CEO should be put in prison...

                                                                        • Willem Kroon
                                                                          Willem Kroon  10 hours back

                                                                          Pity, the music on this video is disturbed by a talking man.
                                                                          Make the music even louder so you can forget the voice-over totally.

                                                                          • Rick S
                                                                            Rick S  10 hours back

                                                                            Oh we forgot to tell the pilots about MCAS system.....we bad....

                                                                            • wellwhatthen10101
                                                                              wellwhatthen10101  10 hours back

                                                                              What do you expect Boeing and USA don' t like being second best they where beaten by UK being the first to bring a jet passenger plain the comet and, " but had a design fault and was taken out of service " could not bring out a supersonic passenger plane. The UK and French Concorde and the Airbus A380. That showed how to make a plane that was better than the Boeing 737. Then this had to be icing on the cake trying to modify The 737 because the Airbus A320 was yet again the better aircraft. It sounds if someone in the US F A A was getting backhanders for allowing this the licence of airworthiness now at what cost.Shame on the USA.

                                                                              • Snetmot Nosrorb
                                                                                Snetmot Nosrorb  7 hours back

                                                                                US authorities are mostly working to make business better rather than making sure companies follow regulations.

                                                                            • Ahmad Dan-Hamidu
                                                                              Ahmad Dan-Hamidu  10 hours back

                                                                              What I don't yet understand is that:
                                                                              "If the Ethiopian pilots electrically disabled their MCAS, then why was it too late for them to control their 737 and get it out of the dive that killed them? My thinking is that with the MCAS disabled, they would manually retrim the elevators for a positive feel that would facilitate pulling their yokes back to secure a transition from dive to climb before running out of altitude...or were they already too close to the ground when they successfully disabled the MCAS?"
                                                                              Just my thoughts.

                                                                              • Bill S
                                                                                Bill S  10 hours back

                                                                                Vox negates to state that the pilots in question re-engaged the system 11 times and eventually left it operating. They had very little time behind the stick of any plane. Pilot 101, if it isn't working and you can fly without it, leave it alone. Boeing definitely needed to disclose this new system, but those airlines come from a "safety 3rd" environment.

                                                                                • Joseph hakim
                                                                                  Joseph hakim  10 hours back

                                                                                  Y’all need to learn about aerodynamics and the faa some more, because the amount of testing planes get into are insane

                                                                                  • ViralTaco
                                                                                    ViralTaco  11 hours back

                                                                                    4:33 The pilot asked to check the handbook? WTF
                                                                                    What about the memory items? Weren't the pilots trained?
                                                                                    So it's not Boeing's fault. It's the god damn airline for not training their pilots properly.

                                                                                    • Shadow program
                                                                                      Shadow program  12 hours back

                                                                                      "this is an airplane engine"

                                                                                      oi cheers mate i thought it was an exotic turtle

                                                                                      • Yousef Albasti
                                                                                        Yousef Albasti  13 hours back

                                                                                        Just make the landing gear taller

                                                                                      • mailangels
                                                                                        mailangels  13 hours back

                                                                                        I am an aerospace engineer working in the industry. The man is right in that the MCAS system needs to removed ENTIRELY and not just have a software update with additional sensor readings. That the 737max aircraft airframe is inherently instable, is unacceptable for a civil aviation aircraft. This necessitates a complete redesign of the 737-max aircraft to be inherently stable.

                                                                                        It is also very dangerous for gliding if the engine fails

                                                                                        • geams
                                                                                          geams  14 hours back

                                                                                          If that plane was made by VW, the CEO would go to jail, the company would have to buy all planes back and all flight tickets ever purchased for that model would be reimbursed.
                                                                                          American companies get away with everything, their international competitors are driven to extinction by American courts.

                                                                                          • Hategplus crevis
                                                                                            Hategplus crevis  15 hours back

                                                                                            That is absolutely disgusting !! That is a major design flaw that needs a drastic rethink but they just come up with a workaround putting peoples lives at risk. Unbelievable.